
The ideal man bears the accidents of life with dignity
and grace, making the best of circumstances.—Aristotle
That’s Stan Foreman. I found him in the June 2016 alumni magazine from The University of Washington, Columns. Gary recognized him right away. But then yes, I could see it too.
Stan is a part of my family history, though he is (was) not family at all, and might be said to have done as much harm as good. He was a junkie soon after we met and for most of his life, but the story is a little more complicated than that.
My husband held out our university alumni magazine to me. A head shot fills more than half a page, “Stan Foreman” in the caption, and even I could see it was the Stan we once knew, still alive. He smiles in the photo, but he’s not the Stan I once knew. For many years I told my students a story about Stan, an object lesson about the kind boy who did me a good turn before he turned himself.
In Seventh Grade Art I used my own soft drawing pencil to draw, pressing hard until the paper glinted metallic black. Finally, I put my pencil down and I got up to wash my graphite-smudged fingers. When I returned, my drawing was there on the table, but my pencil had vanished. I searched the floor, turned a backwards circle. Two older boys snickered at a table behind mine. And then, a boy even shorter and slighter than me stood between us and yelled at those boys, “You took Jan’s pencil. I saw you. Give it back!” The ruckus caught the attention of the teacher, and my pencil was returned.
That is how I met Stan Foreman.
We went to different high schools after ninth grade, but our paths crossed because of shared interests and friends. Through high school, I was always glad to see that boy who had stuck up for me when I was eleven. This was the sixties. We all had such pretty dreams of flowers and peace and walks in quiet stillness when we were young. At a time when people still dated, I never dated Stan, but we met up at music concerts, parties, and picnics—Barb and Randy, Janet and Rae, people who also knew Gary, the boy I would love forever.
After high school, I went on to attend the University of Washington and I worked at the University Book Store music department. One busy day, someone came into the store as I waited on a line of customers.
“Hey, Jan!”
I looked up and beamed. “Stan! How are you?”
“I’m great, you still with Gary?”
“Yeah.”
“That’s cool, that’s cool,” he said and moved deeper into the store.
I was busy at the register when he returned to the front and opened the door to leave. “Tell Gary I said hi.”
We waved and he was gone. But there had been something odd about the shape of his Army surplus jacket, the angle of his arm when he left the store. As soon as I finished with my last customer, I walked through the store and found a bin completely emptied of records. Fifteen or twenty record albums gone just like that.
I absolutely knew Stan had done it. He had greeted me as a friend to cover his theft. I didn’t know what I felt was worst—the arrogance or the betrayal?
“Stan Foreman was in the store today and he ripped me off,” I said later to Gary as I took off my coat.
“He’s still alive?”
“What do you mean?” I said. “Of course, and he ripped off the store!”
“Well, yeah.”
“What do you mean ‘Well, yeah’? He stole a whole bin of Hundred and One Strings!”
“Yeah, that’s dumb. He won’t be able to sell them, but Stan he was probably high. You know he’s a junkie. Since school. You knew that,” he said, finally looking at me. “Didn’t you?”
And then the sordid story poured out. Stan was already using heroin in junior high school when we were in Mrs. Ice’s History class and had Mr. Shipman for English. Even then. He had, over the years, stolen money and instruments from friends and family. His father was a mean drunk and beat him. Stan beat up his girlfriend in high school. More recently, old friends did not want him to know where they lived. No one trusted him.
The boy who saved my pencil was no longer one of the good guys.
This is not the end of the story.
#
Years later at a party before Gary and I moved to Oregon in 1979, someone commented, “I saw Stan Foreman the other day.”
Three people simultaneously turned their heads and said, “He’s still alive?” I was one of the three.
He had been spotted trying to steal audio cassettes—that same old pattern. Stealing music to pay for his habit. It is terrible to say, but no one was relieved at the news of Stan’s continued existence. There was no thank-goodness tone in our remark, no how-cool-is-that?-relief. We were merely surprised he hadn’t overdosed yet. The way you might be surprised to learn the cucumber you’d forgotten in the crisper for a month had turned fuzzy but not dissolved into moldy slush.
#
In the late 80s, Gary’s brother Eric said it again: “I saw Stan Foreman the other day.”
Eric was shopping at Tower Records in Seattle where Stan was making a mess of stealing CDs. That is, he was in worse shape than ever, but accompanied by a little girl wearing a dirty dress with a strung-out, and much younger woman waiting on the sidewalk. Eric was distressed by that little girl and his breath went shaky in and out as he told the story. He wanted to laugh, but could not quite pull it off. The child was about two, he said, and he recognized her age because he had a two year old daughter of his own by then.
This is where the story I told my students ends. I would describe my dismay and disappointment that a boy I once liked had turned out so badly. I would express amazement that any junkie could live so long so carelessly. I would reveal my shocking lack of compassion for that boy I went to school with and how his life turned bad. We talked, sometimes, about people getting lost.
There were nearly thirty-four thousand students at the University of Washington in the years I attended. Stan Foreman was not among them. He held jobs, never for more than a few weeks, but according to Columns Stan was still alive. He is described as charming and not looking bad for a 64 year old man who has lived the life he has. The author reports that Stan joked how despite his long abuse of drugs, it is smoking that is killing him. The drugs Stan used those days were intended to ease his suffering into death.
The author reports Stan maintains contact with some of his family, an ex-wife and three children. I do not know if one of the children is that long ago little girl waiting on the sidewalk while her daddy shoplifts from a music store. I try not to think about her. I should feel sad for Stan. Glad for the support of family. I want to feel something different from what I feel, which is a fluttering of many things and no desire to call him up and tell him I care. I am not sure I do.
Stan did damage, maybe serious damage to people who loved him. I turn the magazine page to see the close-up photo of Stan, smiling. I have already felt sorry, for years now, about that boy who was kind to me and how he lived long enough to damage a child’s life. I stare and stare at the photos in the magazine, the picture of his tiny apartment, the books he reads, the face that echoes somebody I used to like.
Over the years my schoolmates have found their various lives and deaths. Madora and Toni and Rin are retired. Denise married three times before she found her soulmate. My old friends have accomplished remarkable things, interesting things, the ones who lived. Randy and Janet disappeared from my life. Barb and Don and Tom left forever before I could say goodbye. Kinder and smarter people did not last so long on earth as Stan.
I search in myself for the goodness to forgive him. He would have remembered me, I am sure. Maybe he would have recalled that long ago pencil, that long ago stack of record albums. Or not. Why would he need my forgiveness for stealing a rack of pop music vinyl all those years ago? Compassion struggles in my heart. What wins out in my memory, the boy in the classroom or the man in the store?
Today I return to study the photographs.
An oxygen line runs above his smile. A few days’ beard. I search for some remnant of that brave adolescent boy who befriended me. I search for sufficient virtue in myself, the right to judge. Yes, Stan’s smile charms, anyone can see the once-was sweet boy in the photographs. He tells the reporter he is grateful for the visits of hospice workers. He might have been fifteen when he took a car and drove it through a fence. It did not occur to him that was stealing, he did worse. He did whatever came up as a means to get high, stay high, and stay alive long enough to get high the next day. My husband says he was always stretching the bounds to see how far he could go before things broke. Maybe that is how he got so lost.
The article says Stan liked to tell stories of being a hippie in the 60s. Stan had Dickens and Twain and Freud on his shelter bookshelves, and I think the author of the magazine article, like me, must be drawn by that. We want to care about him, but some of us who wander are indeed lost. When the news comes, it is too late for tears, too late for reconciliation. He has died. I sit and stare at the photograph, unmoved. It is not only Stan who fails at grace.






President Trump holds a card with talking points during a listening session with high school students and teachers on gun violence on Wednesday, Feb. 21, 2018. (Ricky Carioti/The Washington Post)
(Carolyn Kaster/AP)





